Page:
Home > Show Us Yours! > Catastrophic Failure

GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

I think I'll let the pics do the talking

















Myself and Paul started making a replacement engine today. It's a 1380 with an SW10 cam

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


fastcarl

User Avatar

6966 Posts
Member #: 507
Fastest A Series Mini in the World

leeds/wakefield.

i think i can pinpoint your main problem,
excesive over use of hermatite, gasket sealant, leading ot oil contamination , and subsequent breakdown of running clearances leading to to your rod bowing out,

WWW.FORCE-RACING.CO.UK PLEASE CLICK HERE


Rod S

User Avatar

5988 Posts
Member #: 2024
Formally Retired

Rural Suffolk

Bad luck.....

I'm guessing big end bolt(s) came loose on that rod, maybe failed but at least one seems intact in the 11th photo.

The cap is certainly off the rod in the 4th photo and the bearing shells have spun in the 5th.....

Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ???


Andrew 998 mini

User Avatar

54 Posts
Member #: 5639
Advanced Member

Weert Holland

haven't seen an engine kill its self like that for a while.....

I'd say the same as fast carl , rather a lot of instant gaskit all over, possible cause.

what Rpm did she go out?

Cheers, Andrew

______________________________________________________
Little car Little power........... For now That is!!!!!

1983 mini down paid, must collect soon and get welding!
______________________________________________________


James_H

User Avatar

3692 Posts
Member #: 1833
Formally mini_majic

Auckland, New Zealand

Nice!!!


time for a certain head............ haha


Kean

User Avatar

2406 Posts
Member #: 341
aka T2clubby

South Staffs



Unlucky


GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

Lads, the cause was running with no oil. Oil pressure light came on whilst driving on the motorway *surprised* so I put 3 litres in to get it to minimum. Then kept driving it. the rod that failed was furthest from the oil pump. There wasn't enough oil to get to that end of the block, the big end bearing failed and I kept driving it until the rod snapped. The big end bolts were fine

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


Sprocket

User Avatar

11046 Posts
Member #: 965
Post Whore

Preston On The Brook

I don't think the location of the oil pump had any bearing on which rod fialed first (excuse the puhn)

If you had to put 3 litres oil in it, that should have told you something *hehe!*

A perfectly good engine and box just wasted, you lot must have money to burn

*wink**wink*

Edited by Sprocket on 4th Apr, 2009.

On 26th Oct, 2004 TurboDave16v said:
Is it A-Series only? I think it should be...
So when some joey comes on here about how his 16v turbo vauxhall is great compared to ours, he can be given the 'bird'...


On 26th Oct, 2004 Tom Fenton said:
Yep I agree with TD........


GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

It wasn't a perfectly good box Sprocket. Second gear synchros were wanked

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


Vegard

User Avatar

7765 Posts
Member #: 74
I pick holes in everything..

Chief ancient post excavator

Norway




On 4th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:
It wasn't a perfectly good box Sprocket. Second gear synchros were wanked


Well a perfectly good core for rebuilding is still shagged. I'd pay £300 for that!

Why keep on driving with no oil?

On 13th Jul, 2012 Ben H said:
Mine gets in the way a bit, but only when it is up. If it is down it does not cause a problem.



joeybaby83

User Avatar

6274 Posts
Member #: 509
Post Whore

Isle of Man

yar, that'd be fucked that'd be

"Turbo's make torque, and torque makes fun"

"did you know you can toast potato waffles?"



PaulH

User Avatar

1346 Posts
Member #: 2340
Post Whore

Dublin Ireland

Ok lads Gary went for his NCT on friday last week. He filled it with
oil and went his
way. On tuesday he went for a spin to a local river about 200miles from dublin which the car done no problam. On his way home, about 20miles from home the oil light flicked on on a down shif,he then stoped in the nearest garrage and put in 3L of oil. Drove it anouther few miles when engine lost power very quickly after that the rod broke, bear in mind this all happened at motorway speeds, where this type of failure hapens very quickly. The engine block is a wright of the gearbox is NOT, it needs a small patch and a little clean and it will
fight another day :)

Edited by PaulH on 4th Apr, 2009.

On 17th Feb, 2009 Rob H said:

I find the easiest way is to super glue the bolt to the end of one of my fingers.

______________________________________________________


Spaceboy

User Avatar

12 Posts
Member #: 1783
Member

Adelaide, Australia

would it have been cheaper to get a tow truck?

how fast do you go on the motorway?

good to see a replacement is already underway!

Aussie Supercharged 1360 Clubby


PaulH

User Avatar

1346 Posts
Member #: 2340
Post Whore

Dublin Ireland

The limit is 120Kph

And it did end on a toe truck

On 17th Feb, 2009 Rob H said:

I find the easiest way is to super glue the bolt to the end of one of my fingers.

______________________________________________________


AlexF2003

5795 Posts
Member #: 80
AFRacing LTD

Newbury, Berks

Thread Cleaned - keep it nice on here folks...

AlexF


Rod S

User Avatar

5988 Posts
Member #: 2024
Formally Retired

Rural Suffolk

On 4th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:

Whats up with the anti-Irish sentiment?


Not from me, although you did confuse me by throwing the rod end cap into the gearbox after you had dismantled it making me think the bolts had come undone or broken causing the failure.......

I'm glad the gearbox casing is repairable - it looks like a 3 bolt retainer type - It took me ages last year to get hold of one of them.

One lesson is to have a pressure gauge, not just the standard light - there is an old saying that the standard oil warning light only tells you that the engine has just failed....

Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ???


Coupe

User Avatar

998 Posts
Member #: 2178
Post Whore

Leyland, Lancs

On 4th Apr, 2009 Rod S said:
One lesson is to have a pressure gauge, not just the standard light - there is an old saying that the standard oil warning light only tells you that the engine has just failed....


Agreed - I couldn't do without my pressure gauge now, and my temperature gauge - I'd say they were invaluable, especially on an A-Series!

On 15th Jul, 2009 fastcarl said:
a breif struggle ensued but Will emerged the victor with a pair of undies in his possesion


On 21st Sep, 2009 apbellamy said:
No, but you did chuck your guts up over my front gate the Saturday before! You even managed to get a bit in your arm pit...


BENROSS

User Avatar

9812 Posts
Member #: 332
Resident Cylinder Head Modifier

Mitsi Evo 7, 911, Cossie. & all the chavs ...... won no problem

bad luck !

as soo as the oil light came on you should have shut down the engine pronto !

any way its a costly mistake lads






MikeRace

User Avatar

6549 Posts
Member #: 1149
#1 Basshunter Fan

Force Racing ICT Dept Manager Miglia Turbo Am frum Yokshyer tha noes!

We all say shut the engine down, but who does when ur miles from home! I didnt and it cost me my turbo and thrusts. Lucky really.

1/4 Mile 14.3secs 96Mph Terminal 10psi of boost.


Fibreglass Parts? - http://www.tdkracing.co.uk/
Split Rims? - http://www.force-racing.co.uk/


AlexF2003

5795 Posts
Member #: 80
AFRacing LTD

Newbury, Berks

On 4th Apr, 2009 MikeRace said:
We all say shut the engine down, but who does when ur miles from home! I didnt and it cost me my turbo and thrusts. Lucky really.


Erm most people...

AlexF


Sprocket

User Avatar

11046 Posts
Member #: 965
Post Whore

Preston On The Brook

Fair enough but if it needed three litres of oil to get it to the minimum, surely sense would say that the oil you have just put in is going the same way as the original oil.

Three litres plus of oil lost is not just an oil leak now is it.

I think what spaceboy was saying is that it would have been cheaper to get the tow truck at the point of relising the engine had lost 3 litres of oil, at least the engine would still be in one piece and the box wouldnt have a hole in it. Either way there is the cost of the tow.

Having said that, its made way for a bigger engine, and a few mantle trophies, which is not such a bad thing after all now is it *happy*

Its an easy way to make raised crown pistons. I asume it was a 12g940 head?

On 26th Oct, 2004 TurboDave16v said:
Is it A-Series only? I think it should be...
So when some joey comes on here about how his 16v turbo vauxhall is great compared to ours, he can be given the 'bird'...


On 26th Oct, 2004 Tom Fenton said:
Yep I agree with TD........


GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

Rod, that wasn't directed at you. Did I quote you by mistake? If so, I apologise.

The conrod (using the full name to differenciate from your name *tongue* ) end cap was actually just as the picture showed when I separated engine from box. However, the bolts had good thread as did the conrod. It appears that they simply vibrated out as a result of the knocking.

I will fix the gearbox in the next couple of weeks. I need to find a second gear though as it is rough and has been since long before I bought the car.

I completely agree about the standard light and its function. I believe it comes on at 4psi!

If anyone is still a bit confused by me driving after the light came on, there are a few reasons. I knew the engine was coming out for some serious work once the light came on. Also, the engine was built for the cost of a diff pin and gasket set. I had bearings and rings spare from the first iteration of the engine build that is now the 1098 turbo. Thirdly, I was getting ring gaps of almost 1mm and the ringlands were sloppy when building the engine. So an overbore and pistons were needed anyway.


I'm back on the road now anyway. 1380 with pre-verto clutch, a rebuilt gearbox and megajolt. I just need a stronger diaphragm to stop clutch slip.

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


Rod S

User Avatar

5988 Posts
Member #: 2024
Formally Retired

Rural Suffolk

On 5th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:
Rod, that wasn't directed at you. Did I quote you by mistake? If so, I apologise.
No, bits of the thread have (rightly) been edited by the mods since I posted, so what I said doesn't quite make sense now... not a problem :)


On 5th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:
The conrod (using the full name to differenciate from your name *tongue* ) end cap was actually just as the picture showed when I separated engine from box. However, the bolts had good thread as did the conrod. It appears that they simply vibrated out as a result of the knocking.


Ahhhhh..... so the cap WAS off when you took it apart.

If so I stand by my first guess - cap came loose leading to the bearing shells spinning and allowing the piston to hit the head.

IMO it is unlikely vibration from a failed bearing would have vibrated the bolts loose.

However, because they don't have locktabs, I always assemble the main and big end bolts with Loctite 270 just in case...

If it did happen the other way around, ie, bearing failed and then cap came loose, it suggests the shells weren't a good fit in the conrod or hadn't been "crushed" properly, so the cap wasn't sitting hard on the conrod face as it should be. If it wasn't sitting hard and was being held off by the shells, then when they span and destroyed themselves, the cap would become loose.

Equally if the shells weren't sitting right in that conrod, it could explain why that bigend (only) failed on low oil pressure.

However, whatever the order, IMO the major damage is because the cap came off *frown*

Edited by Rod S on 5th Apr, 2009.

Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ???


Sprocket

User Avatar

11046 Posts
Member #: 965
Post Whore

Preston On The Brook



However, because they don't have locktabs, I always assemble the main and big end bolts with Loctite 270 just in case...



You do what?! *surprised*

That's one way of expecting a failure*oh well*

On 26th Oct, 2004 TurboDave16v said:
Is it A-Series only? I think it should be...
So when some joey comes on here about how his 16v turbo vauxhall is great compared to ours, he can be given the 'bird'...


On 26th Oct, 2004 Tom Fenton said:
Yep I agree with TD........


PaulH

User Avatar

1346 Posts
Member #: 2340
Post Whore

Dublin Ireland

Have to agree with Colin, Rod using loctite on rod bolts is a very bad idea.

The cap most defently did not come lose first.

On 17th Feb, 2009 Rob H said:

I find the easiest way is to super glue the bolt to the end of one of my fingers.

______________________________________________________

Home > Show Us Yours! > Catastrophic Failure
Users viewing this thread: none. (+ 1 Guests)   Next ->
To post messages you must be logged in!
Username: Password:
Page: