| Page: |
| Home > Show Us Yours! > Catastrophic Failure | |||||||
![]() 1424 Posts Member #: 2810 Formally spanner181187 Dublin, Ireland |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:10:58pm
I think I'll let the pics do the talking
On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:
I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse ![]() On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best |
||||||
![]() 6966 Posts Member #: 507 Fastest A Series Mini in the World leeds/wakefield. |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:33:32pm
i think i can pinpoint your main problem,
|
||||||
|
5988 Posts Member #: 2024 Formally Retired Rural Suffolk |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:33:37pm
Bad luck.....
Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ??? |
||||||
![]() 54 Posts Member #: 5639 Advanced Member Weert Holland |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:41:08pm
haven't seen an engine kill its self like that for a while.....
Cheers, Andrew
|
||||||
![]() 3692 Posts Member #: 1833 Formally mini_majic Auckland, New Zealand |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:42:57pm
Nice!!!
|
||||||
![]() 2406 Posts Member #: 341 aka T2clubby South Staffs |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:43:15pm
|
||||||
![]() 1424 Posts Member #: 2810 Formally spanner181187 Dublin, Ireland |
3rd Apr, 2009 at 11:45:55pm
Lads, the cause was running with no oil. Oil pressure light came on whilst driving on the motorway On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:
I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse ![]() On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best |
||||||
![]() 11046 Posts Member #: 965 Post Whore Preston On The Brook |
4th Apr, 2009 at 12:35:45am
I don't think the location of the oil pump had any bearing on which rod fialed first (excuse the puhn)
Edited by Sprocket on 4th Apr, 2009. On 26th Oct, 2004 TurboDave16v said:
Is it A-Series only? I think it should be... So when some joey comes on here about how his 16v turbo vauxhall is great compared to ours, he can be given the 'bird'... On 26th Oct, 2004 Tom Fenton said:
Yep I agree with TD........ |
||||||
![]() 1424 Posts Member #: 2810 Formally spanner181187 Dublin, Ireland |
4th Apr, 2009 at 12:45:13am
It wasn't a perfectly good box Sprocket. Second gear synchros were wanked On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:
I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse ![]() On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best |
||||||
![]() 7765 Posts Member #: 74 I pick holes in everything.. Chief ancient post excavator |
4th Apr, 2009 at 07:44:50am
On 4th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:
It wasn't a perfectly good box Sprocket. Second gear synchros were wanked Well a perfectly good core for rebuilding is still shagged. I'd pay £300 for that! Why keep on driving with no oil? On 13th Jul, 2012 Ben H said:
Mine gets in the way a bit, but only when it is up. If it is down it does not cause a problem. |
||||||
![]() 6274 Posts Member #: 509 Post Whore Isle of Man |
4th Apr, 2009 at 08:48:06am
yar, that'd be fucked that'd be "Turbo's make torque, and torque makes fun"
|
||||||
![]() 1346 Posts Member #: 2340 Post Whore Dublin Ireland |
4th Apr, 2009 at 09:54:39am
Ok lads Gary went for his NCT on friday last week. He filled it with
Edited by PaulH on 4th Apr, 2009. On 17th Feb, 2009 Rob H said:
I find the easiest way is to super glue the bolt to the end of one of my fingers. ______________________________________________________ |
||||||
![]() 12 Posts Member #: 1783 Member Adelaide, Australia |
4th Apr, 2009 at 11:28:25am
would it have been cheaper to get a tow truck?
Aussie Supercharged 1360 Clubby |
||||||
![]() 1346 Posts Member #: 2340 Post Whore Dublin Ireland |
4th Apr, 2009 at 11:57:22am
The limit is 120Kph
On 17th Feb, 2009 Rob H said:
I find the easiest way is to super glue the bolt to the end of one of my fingers. ______________________________________________________ |
||||||
|
5795 Posts Member #: 80 AFRacing LTD Newbury, Berks |
4th Apr, 2009 at 02:16:06pm
Thread Cleaned - keep it nice on here folks... AlexF |
||||||
|
5988 Posts Member #: 2024 Formally Retired Rural Suffolk |
4th Apr, 2009 at 02:16:43pm
On 4th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:
Whats up with the anti-Irish sentiment? Not from me, although you did confuse me by throwing the rod end cap into the gearbox after you had dismantled it making me think the bolts had come undone or broken causing the failure....... I'm glad the gearbox casing is repairable - it looks like a 3 bolt retainer type - It took me ages last year to get hold of one of them. One lesson is to have a pressure gauge, not just the standard light - there is an old saying that the standard oil warning light only tells you that the engine has just failed.... Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ??? |
||||||
|
998 Posts Member #: 2178 Post Whore Leyland, Lancs |
4th Apr, 2009 at 03:01:25pm
On 4th Apr, 2009 Rod S said:
One lesson is to have a pressure gauge, not just the standard light - there is an old saying that the standard oil warning light only tells you that the engine has just failed.... Agreed - I couldn't do without my pressure gauge now, and my temperature gauge - I'd say they were invaluable, especially on an A-Series! On 15th Jul, 2009 fastcarl said:
a breif struggle ensued but Will emerged the victor with a pair of undies in his possesion On 21st Sep, 2009 apbellamy said:
No, but you did chuck your guts up over my front gate the Saturday before! You even managed to get a bit in your arm pit... |
||||||
![]() 9812 Posts Member #: 332 Resident Cylinder Head Modifier Mitsi Evo 7, 911, Cossie. & all the chavs ...... won no problem |
4th Apr, 2009 at 03:39:45pm
bad luck !
|
||||||
![]() 6549 Posts Member #: 1149 #1 Basshunter Fan Force Racing ICT Dept Manager Miglia Turbo Am frum Yokshyer tha noes! |
4th Apr, 2009 at 04:15:39pm
We all say shut the engine down, but who does when ur miles from home! I didnt and it cost me my turbo and thrusts. Lucky really. 1/4 Mile 14.3secs 96Mph Terminal 10psi of boost.
|
||||||
|
5795 Posts Member #: 80 AFRacing LTD Newbury, Berks |
4th Apr, 2009 at 06:48:01pm
On 4th Apr, 2009 MikeRace said:
We all say shut the engine down, but who does when ur miles from home! I didnt and it cost me my turbo and thrusts. Lucky really. Erm most people... AlexF |
||||||
![]() 11046 Posts Member #: 965 Post Whore Preston On The Brook |
4th Apr, 2009 at 09:26:25pm
Fair enough but if it needed three litres of oil to get it to the minimum, surely sense would say that the oil you have just put in is going the same way as the original oil.
On 26th Oct, 2004 TurboDave16v said:
Is it A-Series only? I think it should be... So when some joey comes on here about how his 16v turbo vauxhall is great compared to ours, he can be given the 'bird'... On 26th Oct, 2004 Tom Fenton said:
Yep I agree with TD........ |
||||||
![]() 1424 Posts Member #: 2810 Formally spanner181187 Dublin, Ireland |
5th Apr, 2009 at 12:06:06am
Rod, that wasn't directed at you. Did I quote you by mistake? If so, I apologise.
On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:
I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse ![]() On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best |
||||||
|
5988 Posts Member #: 2024 Formally Retired Rural Suffolk |
5th Apr, 2009 at 07:49:00am
On 5th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said: No, bits of the thread have (rightly) been edited by the mods since I posted, so what I said doesn't quite make sense now... not a problem :)
Rod, that wasn't directed at you. Did I quote you by mistake? If so, I apologise. On 5th Apr, 2009 GaryOS said:
The conrod (using the full name to differenciate from your name ) end cap was actually just as the picture showed when I separated engine from box. However, the bolts had good thread as did the conrod. It appears that they simply vibrated out as a result of the knocking.Ahhhhh..... so the cap WAS off when you took it apart. If so I stand by my first guess - cap came loose leading to the bearing shells spinning and allowing the piston to hit the head. IMO it is unlikely vibration from a failed bearing would have vibrated the bolts loose. However, because they don't have locktabs, I always assemble the main and big end bolts with Loctite 270 just in case... If it did happen the other way around, ie, bearing failed and then cap came loose, it suggests the shells weren't a good fit in the conrod or hadn't been "crushed" properly, so the cap wasn't sitting hard on the conrod face as it should be. If it wasn't sitting hard and was being held off by the shells, then when they span and destroyed themselves, the cap would become loose. Equally if the shells weren't sitting right in that conrod, it could explain why that bigend (only) failed on low oil pressure. However, whatever the order, IMO the major damage is because the cap came off
Edited by Rod S on 5th Apr, 2009. Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ??? |
||||||
![]() 11046 Posts Member #: 965 Post Whore Preston On The Brook |
5th Apr, 2009 at 09:52:31am
However, because they don't have locktabs, I always assemble the main and big end bolts with Loctite 270 just in case... You do what?!
That's one way of expecting a failure
On 26th Oct, 2004 TurboDave16v said:
Is it A-Series only? I think it should be... So when some joey comes on here about how his 16v turbo vauxhall is great compared to ours, he can be given the 'bird'... On 26th Oct, 2004 Tom Fenton said:
Yep I agree with TD........ |
||||||
![]() 1346 Posts Member #: 2340 Post Whore Dublin Ireland |
5th Apr, 2009 at 10:29:57am
Have to agree with Colin, Rod using loctite on rod bolts is a very bad idea.
On 17th Feb, 2009 Rob H said:
I find the easiest way is to super glue the bolt to the end of one of my fingers. ______________________________________________________ |
||||||
| Home > Show Us Yours! > Catastrophic Failure | |||||||
|
|||||||
| Page: |








so I put 3 litres in to get it to minimum. Then kept driving it. the rod that failed was furthest from the oil pump. There wasn't enough oil to get to that end of the block, the big end bearing failed and I kept driving it until the rod snapped. The big end bolts were fine







) end cap was actually just as the picture showed when I separated engine from box. However, the bolts had good thread as did the conrod. It appears that they simply vibrated out as a result of the knocking.