Page:
Home > Help Needed / General Tech Chat > Ignition Management Systems

t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

Hi

I'm doing some reading about IMS and although i had a MJ on my previous mini i've stumbled across SC A-Series Storm Kit slightly more expensive than what you could get a MJ i.e

MJ (off the site inc hangers, cable and hard limiter) £121.80
MED Bracket and Pickup £60
MED Lightweight Pulley with Engine management pick up £73.40
EDIS/Coil £25 (ish)
Total £280.20

Now the SC Storm kit costs £345 and i think i still need a coil.

I'm just curious as to if there are any benefits to the Storm Kit for the extra £65 having not used one and what you people think generally is better.

Atm the MJ still seems like the better deal.....but there could be some hidden gems.

t

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


Rod S

User Avatar

5988 Posts
Member #: 2024
Formally Retired

Rural Suffolk

Do you have a link to the Storm kit ???

If it still needs a coil (as in a single coil) then surely it still needs the dizzy (rotor arm part) ???

Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ???


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

hi

i meant coil pack (i think it requires one) although i believe it has the edis element of the 2 normally required Ford parts in the ecu box

http://www.specialist-components.co.uk/cnb...odCategoryID=35

link also :)

t

Edited by t@z on 30th Sep, 2009.

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


Rod S

User Avatar

5988 Posts
Member #: 2024
Formally Retired

Rural Suffolk

OK yes, from a quick read of the link, a coilpack driven direct from the ECU rather than through an EDIS unit.

Better than Megajolt (which still uses the EDIS module to drive the coilpack) but similar to Megasquirt which, if used for ignition only and built correctly, can also drive the coilpack directly without an EDIS module.

Lots of choices out there now.....

Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ???


Paul S

User Avatar

8604 Posts
Member #: 573
Formerly Axel

Podland

Does the Storm also need the additional MAP sensor?

If you are planning to use it with a turbo, I would say you do.

Saul Bellow - "A great deal of intelligence can be invested in ignorance when the need for illusion is deep."
Stephen Hawking - "The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge."


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

must admit hadnt thought about a MAP sensor just assumed it would come with one as i cant imagine many mini owners use TPS. pictures to small also to work out.

Rod does that mean that a direct driven coilpack is better than an edis one like the MJ?

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


Rod S

User Avatar

5988 Posts
Member #: 2024
Formally Retired

Rural Suffolk

On 30th Sep, 2009 t@z said:
Rod does that mean that a direct driven coilpack is better than an edis one like the MJ?


Well, people will have opinions, but I would say yes - providing it's implemented correctly in the ECU/package.

EDIS was a half way house, Ford's don't use it anymore, their ignition is now done directly from the EMS/ECU module. It had it's advantages at the time (ie, a fail safe / limp home 10 degree advance if EDIS lost the command signal) but putting half the system in one box and the other half in another box is a bit dated.

Also, as a general rule, you will have a lot more control over certain functions (like charge/dwell time) when the ECU is controlling the coilpack directly.

Also, the wiring becomes a lot simpler....

Just my opinion but I'm running Megasquirt with direct control of the coilpack so I may be a bit biased :)

Schrödinger's cat - so which one am I ???


Gaball

User Avatar

334 Posts
Member #: 7169
Gobshite that posts wank videos.

Somerset, UK

Looks like you can buy a MAP sensor for it as an extra so it obviously has the capability to use one :)

Gaball said:
Motorsport Engineering Student
Project Car 1293 Turbo Mini (on a student budget)

On 7th Oct, 2010 apbellamy said:
Carbon but plug?


Gaball

User Avatar

334 Posts
Member #: 7169
Gobshite that posts wank videos.

Somerset, UK

I am assuming the "A series specific package" includes the A series coil and HT leads

Gaball said:
Motorsport Engineering Student
Project Car 1293 Turbo Mini (on a student budget)

On 7th Oct, 2010 apbellamy said:
Carbon but plug?


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

wowweeee so that MAP sensor pushes it to 400+.

Although a bit dated i'm not sure i could justify spending that much money on it especially when i had to play around so much with me SC trigger wheel and pick up sensor bracket kit last time on my old car (had to get longer bolts to space the sensor bracket out further and trim my fan as the trigger hit...weird)

shame as it seems such a simple set up but with an hours wiring can save over £100

Edited by t@z on 1st Oct, 2009.

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

After having a look at the SC kit at the Pod, all their stuff has evolved massively. The twin cam kit is almost a bolt-on job now. I'm sure you won't have any fitting problems this time round

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

actually i have an incline that the a series package contains the map sensor also which is why its a bit more.

does john k read here much would love some bigger pics and bit more detail on it i.e. plus's over the MJ

Edited by t@z on 1st Oct, 2009.

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

He does read here quite regularly. I'm sure he will see the thread next time he is on or maybe you could drop him a PM

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


johnK

1425 Posts
Member #: 690
Post Whore

Norfolk

ok the Storm ignition kit for the Mini A series comprises

ECU with CAN interface/software/basemap etc
Loom (same loom for MAP or TPS)
Trigger kit + sensor (see pics of K engine in show us yours section for new trigger wheel)

due to people running turbo's webers, su's etc options are needed!

so the SU HIF TPS kit is £70
the Weber DCOE TPS kit is £59
coil/leads/A series billet bracket £79
MAP sensor £55

Hope this helps - if you need any techie help please give us a call on 01953 859785

cheers

JK

If Carling made Mini engines
it would probably be like this one!


paul wiginton
Forum Mod

User Avatar

5933 Posts
Member #: 784
9 times Avon Park Class C winner

Milton Keynes

All that shite went straight over my head! Im sticking with a dizzy for now, it still does the job

Paul

I seriously doubt it!


John

User Avatar

10023 Posts
Member #: 1456
Mongo

Barnsley, South Flatcapshire

Do you not think mapped ignition would improve your 1/4's Paul?

If something is worth doing, it's worth doing half of.


paul wiginton
Forum Mod

User Avatar

5933 Posts
Member #: 784
9 times Avon Park Class C winner

Milton Keynes

Not if I dont know how it works

I seriously doubt it!


John

User Avatar

10023 Posts
Member #: 1456
Mongo

Barnsley, South Flatcapshire

Maybe you should investigate if you have some spare time *smiley*

If something is worth doing, it's worth doing half of.


paul wiginton
Forum Mod

User Avatar

5933 Posts
Member #: 784
9 times Avon Park Class C winner

Milton Keynes

Ive read about it loads of times but it still goes over my head.
Everything Ive read on it assumes I understand the terminology and abbreviations, guess Im a bit thick when it comes to this sort of stuff.
I can use spanners and hammers very well though

Paul

I seriously doubt it!


John

User Avatar

10023 Posts
Member #: 1456
Mongo

Barnsley, South Flatcapshire

I wish I could use spanners & hammers half as well as you mate!

If something is worth doing, it's worth doing half of.


GaryOS

User Avatar

1424 Posts
Member #: 2810
Formally spanner181187

Dublin, Ireland

On 1st Oct, 2009 paul wiginton said:
All that shite went straight over my head! Im sticking with a dizzy for now, it still does the job

Paul


Ah, get your finger out Paul. There is nothing more complex to megajolt than a dizzy. If you buy something with a pre-built loom them it's very easy to fit. Then bring it to a rolling road for mapping

On 12th Nov, 2009 Paul S said:

I think Gary OS has taken over my role as the forum smart arse *happy*


On 30th Apr, 2010 Rod S said:
Gary's description is best


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

On 1st Oct, 2009 johnK said:
ok the Storm ignition kit for the Mini A series comprises

ECU with CAN interface/software/basemap etc
Loom (same loom for MAP or TPS)
Trigger kit + sensor (see pics of K engine in show us yours section for new trigger wheel)

due to people running turbo's webers, su's etc options are needed!

so the SU HIF TPS kit is £70
the Weber DCOE TPS kit is £59
coil/leads/A series billet bracket £79
MAP sensor £55

Hope this helps - if you need any techie help please give us a call on 01953 859785

cheers

JK



Options are extra costs? what i'm trying to do is justify it...so currently if i went with your kit i'm looking at.

A series kit: £345
Map Sensor £55
Coil Pack £15
Total £415

At the moment all i can see the difference is that you lose the EDIS (which is nice) and no wiring (also nice) but not £135 nice if you get me.

obviously not used your software i can't say if its better but if i'm honest i wouldn't be mapping it anyway so its not a big concern of mine just got to go to a good place.

its a shame as i love the ease and simplicity of this product so much but i just cant warrant parting with that much when there doesn't appear to be that bigger plus's that i can see.....i want someone to prove me wrong on this :)

Paul, i think you should fit it and let the RR do the tech stuff. i'm no expert at wiring ask supermottolee and even i managed to wire a MJ up with his help.

t

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


paul wiginton
Forum Mod

User Avatar

5933 Posts
Member #: 784
9 times Avon Park Class C winner

Milton Keynes

One problem is that all the sets Ive seen have shit looking wiring, the other thing is which to go for, many on here use MJ with great success, others say its shit, use a quality DTA.
Can anyone link mr to a site that explains it all in English so I understand it all?

I seriously doubt it!


Tom Fenton
Site Admin

User Avatar

15302 Posts
Member #: 337
Fearless Tom Fenton, Avon Park 2007 & 2008 class D winner

&

TM legend.

Rotherham South Yorkshire

Dave, I'll happily explain it to you, ask away via PM if you wish.


On 29th Nov, 2016 madmk1 said:


On 28th Nov, 2016 Rob Gavin said:
I refuse to pay for anything else


Like fuel 😂😂


paul wiginton
Forum Mod

User Avatar

5933 Posts
Member #: 784
9 times Avon Park Class C winner

Milton Keynes

Will do Tom, but will have to try to think what to ask. Firstly whats the difference between MJ, Weber and DTA and their benefits I guess

PS sorry for the thread hyjack

Paul

I seriously doubt it!

Home > Help Needed / General Tech Chat > Ignition Management Systems
Users viewing this thread: none. (+ 1 Guests)   Next ->
To post messages you must be logged in!
Username: Password:
Page: