Page:
Home > Help Needed / General Tech Chat > Cooling advice.

jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

Struggling to keep the minus cool when going for it on track above about 17 degree outside.

Currently I've got a single core dual pass alloy rad in the front. It's pretty tight and not much else will squeeze in I could maybe go dual core. It keeps it cool enough in the summer in traffic and driving around.

Rad is sealed to the front, small 4 inch and a 7 inch fan on the back with no shroud. Using a Davies Craig pump and its flat out and putting the fans on whilst driving. Only seen it hit 100 on the gauge once but it's enough to worry. This temps taken of the stat housing.

I'm thinking that maybe I need a better flow of air through the bay as the original rad side is pretty much blocked completely with the intercooler. I've got a small vent in the back of the bonnet.

I'm thinking move some of the crud on the drivers inner wing and go at it with a hole saw. Everything is tight in the bay and there isn't much escape room, although the bonnet does lift up nicely at speed.

I'm not to sure how much that would help really, but I'm looking for suggestions?






adcyork

User Avatar

539 Posts
Member #: 6807
Post Whore

York

I know it's a gf shell, but to increase surface area that slam panel stiffening rib could be swapped for something smaller like an aluminium U section rivet and bonded on.

Do you have an oil temp sensor? - what temps are you seeing?

Can you fit a larger single fan in place of the 7" & 4" twin set up (I'm thinking probably not due to starter/oil system clearance?

The bonnet vent will be acting as an inlet, not an outlet. The scuttle is a high pressure area, so that will be lifting the bonnet

Finally what core thickness is the rad?

Edited by adcyork on 4th Apr, 2017.


jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

Not a bad idea. I've already removed one rib so could remove that and have two bits of alloy at each side along with a bit more filing around the edges.

I do now, I fitted one yesterday, I'm thinking it's probably getting pretty warm. I've got a small oil cooler and a sandwich stat on the way.

No unfortunately not. I think it might even just be a 6 inch and a 4. Squeezing them in is hard enough. I could maybe cut out the bottom panel and tilt the bottom of the rad forward and fit a bigger fan. But really the car should cool at speed without a need for the fan to kick in.

The vent was more for letting the air out at standstill above the turbo/carb. It's on the back of a bulge wasn't to sure it would do much at speed!

It's 32mm.


Joe C

User Avatar

12307 Posts
Member #: 565
Carlos Fandango

Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex

double check the gauge isnt lying,

tbh that setup looks pretty good, they opnly thing I can suggest is maybe your getting air locks int the thermostat as I cant see a bleed pipe.

On 28th Aug, 2011 Kean said:
At the risk of being sigged...

Joe, do you have a photo of your tool?



http://www.turbominis.co.uk/forums/index.p...9064&lastpost=1

https://joe1977.imgbb.com/



jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

I'll get a probe on it and see.

No, I blanked it off. I bleed it out the sensor. It should also bleed itself through the swirl pot off no.4 (this then goes through turbo to top of rad), at least that's how I planned it would work lol.

I don't think it has air in as the coolant is very clean. I could stick a bolt in the top of the stat to make sure there is not any stuck in there.

Edited by jonny f on 4th Apr, 2017.


D4VE

User Avatar

2975 Posts
Member #: 10749
Post Whore

lowestoft suffolk

Are the fans on the back more of a blockage for air passing through than a help? Is the grille on on the track day? Size wise n exposure wise ud think that was the best setup you could have..

Oil temp wise mines the opposite my coolants always perfect n the oil gets up to 110

On 24th Oct, 2015 jonny f said:
Nothing gets past Dave lol

NOTHING GETS PAST ME!! *tongue*

1/4 mile 14.7 @ 96mph 12psi boost
Showdown class A 2nd place 18.6 @ 69mph


jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

I would think so dave. Not sure what speed they become a hinderance, I hit 100 plus down three straights. The long straight (at bedford) I'm at 110-115 half way along it.

Going by your oil temp, mines probably up there.

I was going to give it a run without the grill on track. It got warmer throughout the day so was right at the end of the day.

Ended up here though on my second lap round so wasn't a good enough test!

Edited by jonny f on 4th Apr, 2017.


D4VE

User Avatar

2975 Posts
Member #: 10749
Post Whore

lowestoft suffolk

Haha bad enough feeling to do that to then open snapchat and know others have seen it *laughing*

On 24th Oct, 2015 jonny f said:
Nothing gets past Dave lol

NOTHING GETS PAST ME!! *tongue*

1/4 mile 14.7 @ 96mph 12psi boost
Showdown class A 2nd place 18.6 @ 69mph


jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

I think pretty much everyone there saw it.
That's the pit straight. Anyone coming in as some numpty caused a red flag right at the end of the day would to *laughing*

A mate that came with me was the artist.


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

not sure if this is relevant but are the fans suckers or blowers?

your set up is similar to mine so i hope i dont have similar problems!!

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy


adcyork

User Avatar

539 Posts
Member #: 6807
Post Whore

York




On 4th Apr, 2017 jonny f said:
Not a bad idea. I've already removed one rib so could remove that and have two bits of alloy at each side along with a bit more filing around the edges.

I do now, I fitted one yesterday, I'm thinking it's probably getting pretty warm. I've got a small oil cooler and a sandwich stat on the way.

No unfortunately not. I think it might even just be a 6 inch and a 4. Squeezing them in is hard enough. I could maybe cut out the bottom panel and tilt the bottom of the rad forward and fit a bigger fan. But really the car should cool at speed without a need for the fan to kick in.

The vent was more for letting the air out at standstill above the turbo/carb. It's on the back of a bulge wasn't to sure it would do much at speed!

It's 32mm.



That's what I was thinking yea

My question regarding the fans was related to the restriction posed by them once the car is moving. Twin fans have two lots of frame work and fan blade centre boss that does nothing other than restrict air flow when the fan isn't (or shouldn't) be operating. I know its challenging to get a single fan to package though.

Understand, it won't be helping create a depression in the engine bay to draw the air out the back of the rad

32mm is plenty, it will be diminishing returns with anything thicker


jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

Hmm, I'll take the small one out and see if it can take it. Might help the bigger one anyway.

Think it will be worth making some holes/a vented panel for the inner wing?

Thanks for all the ideas/help so far.


jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

On 4th Apr, 2017 t@z said:
not sure if this is relevant but are the fans suckers or blowers?

your set up is similar to mine so i hope i dont have similar problems!!


Suckers for sure. When they're on they pull a fair bit of air.

It's fine on the road, it's just track use where it gets a hammering it's not up to the job.


burcy35

177 Posts
Member #: 10990
Advanced Member

Hornsea

I was having the same issue with cooling on the track at 16+ psi.
I have ordered a bespoke made front rad from radtec which is 50mm thick and they say rated enough to cool upto 240hp. But I have a clubman which has a bit more room but I am still going to have to cut into my front panel to fit the rad and fan down low enough below my intercooler. I was also planning on lifting the back of the bonnet to help the air flow through the engine bay better.


Joe C

User Avatar

12307 Posts
Member #: 565
Carlos Fandango

Burnham-on-Crouch, Essex

Of course you can only get x amount of heat out of the head, how much boost /power you running?

On 28th Aug, 2011 Kean said:
At the risk of being sigged...

Joe, do you have a photo of your tool?



http://www.turbominis.co.uk/forums/index.p...9064&lastpost=1

https://joe1977.imgbb.com/



turbodave16v
Forum Mod

10980 Posts
Member #: 17
***16***

SouthPark, Colorado

I'd look at putting some ribbons / tassels under the bonnet l, and using a GoPro to see what the air is doing in there at speed. Perhaps it's simply a lack of air movement. And are you sure you've got enough water movement; not just that your pump is on high so it must be right... perhaps a piece of clear plastic hose may suffice for a short term check- again with the bonnet closed and GoPro....

On 17th Nov, 2014 Tom Fenton said:
Sorry to say My Herpes are no better


Ready to feel Ancient ??? This is 26 years old as of 2022 https://youtu.be/YQQokcoOzeY



turbodave16v
Forum Mod

10980 Posts
Member #: 17
***16***

SouthPark, Colorado

Actually, surely you want your swirl pot connected to your top hose, not the end of your head?

On 17th Nov, 2014 Tom Fenton said:
Sorry to say My Herpes are no better


Ready to feel Ancient ??? This is 26 years old as of 2022 https://youtu.be/YQQokcoOzeY



slater

User Avatar

1030 Posts
Member #: 1291
Post Whore

Suffolk / Birmingham

Could try some vent holes in the inner wings (an a panels too if you want) may improve flow through the cramped engine bay.


gr4h4m

User Avatar

4890 Posts
Member #: 1775
Post Whore

Chester

What stat are you running?

I run a supercharger and I don't care the TB is on the wrong side.
VEMS + 12 PSI + Liquid Intercooler = Small Bore FUN!


cossierick

User Avatar

3074 Posts
Member #: 1348
Post Whore

wakefield West Yorks

http://www.ebay.com/bhp/electric-inline-water-pump

You need one of those beasts !!! Got one on mine and a similar size rad to yours ! Highest ive got on track is 74 degres lol im only running 10psi though


adcyork

User Avatar

539 Posts
Member #: 6807
Post Whore

York




On 4th Apr, 2017 jonny f said:
Hmm, I'll take the small one out and see if it can take it. Might help the bigger one anyway.

Think it will be worth making some holes/a vented panel for the inner wing?

Thanks for all the ideas/help so far.


The front wheel arches are a low pressure area so yes


wil_h

User Avatar

9258 Posts
Member #: 123
Post Whore

Betwix Harrogate and York

This is what I think. All the air entering the grill goes through a rad (either water or IC). This means that the engine block (the bit you're trying to cool) is getting all the hot air removed from it blown straight back over it.

Ultimately, doing this is going to result in a maximum heat rejection.

All the air entering through the rad is exiting under the car, so no cool air is getting to the engine.

Now i know the block is not going to be efficient at absorbing the hot air but it will still have an effect. think of the original mini layout, the engine gets loads of cold air on it. And all the hot air goes out of the side, not back on the engine.

Modern cars with a front rad still allow cold air into the engine bay.

So maybe some holes in the front of the bonnet might help?



Edited by wil_h on 4th Apr, 2017.

Fastest 998 mini in the world? 13.05 1/4 mile 106mph



On 2nd Jan, 2013 fastcarl said:

the design shows a distinct lack of imagination,
talk about starting off with a clean sheet of paper, then not bothering to fucking draw on it,lol

On 20th Apr, 2012 Paul S said:
I'm mainly concerned about swirl in the runners caused by the tangential entry.


Yo-Han

User Avatar

976 Posts
Member #: 3228
Post Whore

North of the Netherlands

Are you running a thermostat or a sleave and using pump to controll the temperature?

Dazed and Confused....


jonny f

User Avatar

2096 Posts
Member #: 9894
Post Whore

Dorking

Gosh I have a lot to respond to! Cheers lads.

Joe, it's 140bhp and 10psi of boost.

Dave, that's a great idea with the go pro. I'm fairly positive the waters flowing around very well. You can hear it with the pump running on its cool down with engine off. It's not a swirl pot as such like that with all the water going through it, it only has a 10mm angled feed and then exits at the bottom to the turbo.

Slater that's what I'm thinking.

Graham/yo-Han it's just a sleeve and it has a controller which follows a set procedure depending on the temperature.

Rick, that translates to roughly the same flow as mine. Using the EWP 80 so around 20 gallons per minute at full chat. You have no inner wings though, hmmmmm.

Adcyork, right, well that sounds reasonable. I think some holes are needed.

Wil_h, thanks for the input, that's a good thought it makes sense really. Although I thought that was one of the problems with the original layout. Hot air going through the rad.
I really don't want to put more holes in the bonnet if I can avoid it. I have one for the air filter already though.

I was hoping someone might just go 'do this' and my problem would be solved hahaha.
How wrong. Seems like a combination of things.

I took it for a short run earlier and the oil was at 90deg, possibly more though as I have the sensor in the sump plug, the temp drops a fair bit with it being in the airflow.

Edited by jonny f on 4th Apr, 2017.


t@z

User Avatar

2054 Posts
Member #: 452
Post Whore

Chester, UK

On 4th Apr, 2017 jonny f said:
On 4th Apr, 2017 t@z said:
not sure if this is relevant but are the fans suckers or blowers?

your set up is similar to mine so i hope i dont have similar problems!!


Suckers for sure. When they're on they pull a fair bit of air.

It's fine on the road, it's just track use where it gets a hammering it's not up to the job.


Good new on the fans as i remember reading suckers were slightly more efficient at cooling than blowers. Piggy backing someones comments are 2 fans necessary, air flow through the rad being blocked etc. Also i notice that the front grill area is basically a wall for cold air. Rather than drilling more holes in the bonnet is there room for a gap between the rad and IC feed (i assume) to allow front cold air to enter the engine bay?

www.twitter.com/lilpinkiy

Home > Help Needed / General Tech Chat > Cooling advice.
Users viewing this thread: none. (+ 1 Guests)   Next ->
To post messages you must be logged in!
Username: Password:
Page: